The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Generations of war haunt heroic 'Elliot'


The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 09/15/2006 

THEATER REVIEW
"Elliot, a Soldier's Fugue"
Grade: A-

8 p.m. Tuesdays-Saturdays; 7:30 Sundays (also 2:30 Saturdays-Sundays). Through Oct. 1. $25-$30. Alliance Theatre, Hertz Stage, 1280 Peachtree St. N.E., Midtown. 404-733-5000; alliancetheatre.org

The verdict: A profoundly moving meditation on the cost of war.

Quiara Alegria Hudes' "Elliot, a Soldier's Fugue" is a lush and evocative tone poem about the way the landscape of the soul is transformed by war. Suggesting that patriotism and patrimony are tied up together in the same blood knot, the play describes the miracle of a heart that's wounded and healed at the same time.

Naturally, it's about love and family.

Directed by Kent Gash on the Alliance Theatre's intimate Hertz Stage, "Elliot" tells the interlocking stories of the Ortiz clan: three generations of Puerto Rican-Americans who serve in Korea, Vietnam and Iraq.

Hopscotching between time and place, we see how Elliot's Grandpop (Gilbert Cruz) found respite in Korea by playing Bach on his silver flute. Elliot's father (Matthew Montelongo) fell in love with Army nurse Ginny (Mary Lynn Owen) while in Vietnam. Elliot (Ivan Quintanilla) ends up joining the Marines, and going off to Iraq at 17, because he wants to be like Pop —- which is kind of heartbreaking, once he realizes how the war messed up his dad.

At the beginning, Hudes' pastiche-like storytelling style feels a little precious and slightly out of focus. But as soon as the monologues kick in —- Ginny talking about how her Philadelphia garden is a sexy patch of Puerto Rico; Elliot in Iraq, fantasizing about what he would order at Denny's —- the images become clear and uncluttered.

There's a certain fugue-like math to the way the stories argue with themselves, the way motifs dance through the text like notes on sheet music. Though the language can elicit a visceral sting, it's just as often a celebration of the sensuality of memory.

The most haunting moments have a hallucinogenic quality. The injured Elliot floats off into oblivion by remembering the time he was happiest —- safe in the cradle of his parents' love. Back home from war in his mother's garden, she tends to his wounds like Christ anointing the sick. The idea that a nurse can be both ministering angel and object of desire flickers through the text, as when Ginny seduces her future husband a la "A Farewell to Arms."

Refreshingly, Hudes explodes all notions that war dramas must make statements about politics and social status. Or that they must be cliched accounts of drug addiction and psychotic flashbacks. Happily, there's no gratuitous violence or bloodletting.

Softly bathed in William H. Grant III's light, Emily Jean Beck's set is a simple rectangular box painted in luxurious greens —- suggesting that the distance between the Garden of Eden and Vietnamese jungle isn't so vast.

While the acting is uniformly good, Quintanilla gives one of the year's most extraordinary performances. At a very young age, Elliot discovers how passion and war grind together to make heroes —- and what a sad, necessary and ennobling thing it is to be a soldier.


Return to full list of plays






 

 

.